One chapter into Kim Edwards‘ latest novel The Lake of Dreams and I was already writing the review in my head. But when I got to the end, everything I had planned to say about it changed.
This piece of contemporary relationship fiction starts off well. Really well. Traveller Lucy Jarrett finds herself in Japan with a steady boyfriend and no job. She feels like she is drifting aimlessly, unsure of where to go from here. Japan’s shaky earth (trust me to pick up a novel that features earthquakes) makes her uneasy, stirring up thoughts she’d rather not think. So when her mother contacts her from America, she decides to go home for a while, to settle things from her past in order to move into the future.
Edwards has stuck with many of the same themes she explored in The Memory Keeper’s Daughter (which I adored) – secrets, guilt, family, and love. Her writing is just as detailed and absorbing too, and I turned each page with both impatience and dread. I couldn’t wait to find out how it all ended, but I wasn’t ready for the story to be over, either.
When I did get to the end, it was a bit like taking a bite of a delicious piece of cake only to realise you’re running late for something and having to cram the rest of it into your mouth as you rush out the door. Surprisingly unsatisfying and nothing to really savour. It seemed like Edwards was in a hurry to tie up every loose end within a couple of pages, and it all felt a little too perfect. I think it would have been better if somethings were left to the reader’s imagination. In fact, had I been the author, I would have chosen another fate for the main character altogether.
I’m sorry to say that the ending for The Lake of Dreams changed this book from “you’ve got to read it!” to “it was okay, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to recommend it” for me.
Am I being unfair? Does the quality of the ending really matter, as long as the beginning and middle are good? What books have you enjoyed reading, only to have that enjoyment ruined by the ending? What books have you read that end exactly as you hoped they would, or even better than you expected?
Like this:
Like Loading...