NZ Post Book Awards – Young Adult Nominations

CoverThere are five Young Adult titles shortlisted for the NZ Post Book Awards. Tonight I will be on a panel discussing them at the opening of the new Te Tai Tamariki premises in Victoria Street.  It seems trite to say the standard is very high, obviously they wouldn’t have been nominated if they weren’t excellent books! Suffice to say, after reading all five, I didn’t have a sense of one particular book as being a clear favourite for the top spot. Each one has its own star appeal. But I think it would be hard to overlook Mandy Hager’s The Crossing and Tanya Roxborogh’s Banquo’s Son for emotional punch.

The Crossing is described on the cover by Margaret Mahy as “1984 for teenagers”. Conceptually it is a brilliant dystopian sci-fi fantasy. The survivors of an ocean liner that has grounded on a tropical island during a world-wide plague outbreak have gradually enslaved the locals. They prey upon them for new slaves and their plague-free blood. It is an appalling vision of what a powerful elite can achieve when morality is thrown out the window. The hero, young Maryam, is the equivalent of Winston Smith – she gradually realises that being one of the privileged chosen is a two-edged sword. And she decides not to stay around to be slowly bled to death.

To be honest  I didn’t find the comparison to 1984 to be particularly relevant when trying to convey to someone else the emotional climate of the story. It is far more like The Handmaid’s Tale than Orwell’s great classic. And it does read like a winner – not surprisingly, because Mandy Hager has already won the LIANZA Esther Glen Award for fiction in 2008 for her novel Smashed.

CoverYesterday, I was privileged to hear Tanya Roxborogh speaking at Avonside Girls’ School about her novel Banquo’s Son. I had intended reading it anyway, but started unenthusiastically with the thought: I have to read five books by … so I had better get moving … My plan was to read a chapter or two, then switch to the Lee Child on my bedside table that constitutes my real reading pleasure. But I found pretty quickly that I didn’t want to put Banquo’s Son down. Like Tanya I had taught Macbeth for years in the classroom and always wondered how Banquo’s children got to be the rulers of Scotland, when the play ends with Malcolm and Donalbain (the dead king’s sons) firmly back in the running. Tanya explores the “what if” raised by the Scottish play and introduces us to a Fleance any mother would be proud to call her own.

She mentioned in her talk that the young man’s face on the cover is not the perfect Fleance she imagined in her dream of him. But I don’t think there were razor blades in medieval Scotland, let alone hot showers and deodorant. It’s a great cover image and it manages to convey the dark elements of the narrative. Although, not a tragedy – in the strictest sense, it is a tale full of sound and fury. Plenty of action for boys and a strong romantic thread for lovers of that genre. It is the first of a trilogy, the next is about to go to print.

So in conclusion, the world of YA literature in New Zealand has plenty to write home about. Although I wondered whether one of these two novels might be the eventual winner, the one that kept me up late on a Saturday night turning pages as quickly as I could, was End of the Alphabet by Fleur Beale. It is a deceptively simple tale of Ruby Yarrow, who decides one day after talking with her friend, that she is not going to be a doormat anymore. If you want to find out more, I recommend you get a copy … it’s not surprising that Fleur’s book is so readable because she is also a past LIANZA Esther Glen Award winner: Juno of Taris in 2009.

But of course, half the fun of literary competitions for readers is trying to guess the winner and I am sure you will have your views on who it should be. I am content to wait and see.

5 thoughts on “NZ Post Book Awards – Young Adult Nominations

  1. HelenL 12 May 2010 / 5:10 pm

    The 3 you mention are all great reads, but I very much enjoyed another of the finalists, James Norcliffe’s “The Loblolly Boy” when I read it last year. Some great characters and a story that displays Norcliffe’s characteristic whimsicality while still retaining emotional depth.

    I have also read finalist Brian Falkner’s “Brain Jack”, cyberpunk scifi in the tradition of William Gibson–a fast-paced story that certainly kept me reading, although I don’t think it has quite the character or plot depth of Gibson, or of Robert J Sawyer’s “www.wake”, which is currently a finalist for this year’s Hugo Awards, to be decided in September.

    The Loblolly Boy, Brain Jack and Hager’s The Crossing are all nominees for the Sir Julius Vogel Award for Best Book: Young Adult (for excellence in SciFi, Fantasy and/or Horror) as well.

    • paskj 12 May 2010 / 5:28 pm

      Yes I have heard great things about the Norcliffe. It is nominated in the Children’s category.Interesting to hear about the Julius Vogel. My uni. lecturer last year said she couldn’t put Brain Jack down.

      • Andrew 12 May 2010 / 5:43 pm

        Each to their own, but I thought Helen Lowe was going easy on Brain Jack. Yes, it’s fast paced, but the characters are two dimensional at best, coat hangers to swing the action off, and the ending sucked big time. I know this sort of two dimensional writing is meant to appeal to blokes but I prefer writing with more depth.

        But Lowe is right when she says that Falkner is writing in a well established cyberpunk tradition pioneered by William Gibson, Neal Stephenson’s Snow Crash, William Jon Williams etc and I think that anyone who has read those authors would be underwhelmed by Brain Jack.

  2. Alice 12 May 2010 / 5:12 pm

    Last year I posted a blog about the NZ Post Awards Young Adult nominations and managed to pick the winner! But this year I think the decison is harder – for me it’s between 2 – The Crossing or The End of the Alphabet!
    The Crossing – is dark, very dark and powerful and spine chilling and, in places, stomach turning. The End of the Alphabet is much lighter, funnier, but still covering some meaningful questions about identity and your place in your family and the world. I started reading this just as a “10 minutes before sleep” at 10:30pm and at 1:30am very bleary eyed I finished – totally unable to put it down.
    Banquo’s Son, I hate to say, I found a bit boring. I’ve lived in some of the places mentioned in the book – but to me it just didn’t feel about Scotland.

    I think The Crossing is possibly the better book, but it is certainly aimed at older Young Adults. Last year Juno of Taris was my 2nd choice, I think the End of the Alphabet is better than that, but this year Beale is my 2nd choice again. I wonder what the judges will think?

    • Alice 13 May 2010 / 3:48 pm

      I’ve just found that copies of the next book in the Blood of the Lamb trilogy – Into the Wilderness – are sitting on the library shelves (well, 1 less copy.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s