Not a book group groupie

Secret scripture
Secret scripture

Are you a book finisher or a giver-upper?  I used to be a dedicated finisher, I would plough my way through long tiresome books, hoping that soon something would happen to make this all worth while – and sometimes it worked.  Shipping News by Annie Proux took me ages to get into, but I’m glad I perservered.  Margaret Atwood’s The Blind assassin and A S Byatt’s The Biographers Tale were two that took their time to impress me – in fact I think I enjoyed both of them more in hindsight!  However of late I have gone off the practice of finishing, and find myself sighing and tossing the book aside if it is failing to impress.  My latest giver upper has been Sebastian Barry’s The Secret Scripture.  It’s had good reviews, but somehow I couldn’t care about the characters and it’s gone on the growing pile of the “not read”! 

This may explain part of my problem with Reading groups.  I have belonged to, and left three!  With each one I have struggled with the idea of reading a book that has to be read, (even if it is one I have willingly chosen myself). I get a feeling of having to read, which somehow takes away the pleasure.  Even the copious amounts of wine and socialising can’t persuade me that reading groups are my thing.  I like to read a book and savour it – on my own,  and I hate it when someone doesn’t like something that I absolutely adored.  Equally as a non finisher, I would often find myself with nothing to say except a lame, “I didn’t like it”.  No reasons, no thoughts or ideas to back me up, just a shrug of my shoulders and a hasty gulp of wine.

If you belong to a fabulous reading group (and I’m sure many people do), then I envy you, but you can breath a sigh of relief because I won’t be knocking at your door wanting to join in the fun!

4 thoughts on “Not a book group groupie

  1. Mo-mo 28 July 2008 / 10:53 am

    I’ve never been in a book club so I’m not sure if I’d like it or not (wine consumption aside). However I know exactly what I would wear to one if I ever got the chance. It would be this lovely T-shirt.

  2. Tom Brown 28 July 2008 / 9:13 pm

    The Book Club TV show was interesting – till I stopped watching it – or they stopped showing it – or I stopped watching TV, or I lost the T-shirt

  3. Jane 29 July 2008 / 9:27 am

    That T-shirt pretty much sums up my reasons for not being a book group type of gal.

    However, I enjoyed the Book Club TV show, it is wonderful hearing about books, reading and listening to reviews etc. Maybe it’s because someone else has done all the work and I can just bask in their enjoyment.

  4. librarykris 29 July 2008 / 12:43 pm

    I’m both a book finished AND a book giver-upper – although that’s usually by accident so i don’t know if it counts. I will struggle through books because I’ve heard that they are great. Sometimes they turn fascinating in teh middle of the book and I neglect all sorts of things to finish the book. Sometimes they remain at the forced-read level. I’ve noticed a worriyng tendancy in myself to really enjoy a book, to get halfway, put it down, forget about it, RAVE about how great it is and then notice that I can’t remember how it ends. (Usually after I’ve returned it to the library.) What’s up with that?? I know I’m usually multi-reading but still…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s